#ef7e12

Hierarchy in Agile Transformation, but How?

 

Barış Erkent // Allianz Türkiye - Agile Coach

In the focus of agility, there is an understanding that is far from the hierarchy that we know. This means more motivated employees and adding value. However, it is not easy to change some habits and find the balance. It's time to take a closer look at the barriers to the agile hierarchy and what can be done to overcome them.

We know that agility is a phenomenon far from hierarchical structures. Because, at the center of agility is creating value by giving importance to roles, competencies and merit rather than titles. Therefore, even though organizations have assigned titles, all members of agile teams are equal. Just as leaders cannot assign works, teams choose the priority ones from the work list and determine the works they can accomplish. It has an organized and empowered working structure to deliver value to customers faster. There is a simple hierarchy, much less than the usual hierarchy patterns. This in turn attracts people with the right kind of talent, ready to take on challenges and responsibilities.

Servant Leadership

We observe that employees adapt quickly to the less hierarchical and flexible structure of agile organizations. When no hierarchy is perceived within the team, all jobs are collectively owned. Healthy discussions arise, independent of seniority and experience. As people relax and see each other as equal, they provide better quality feedback. Removing obstacles with a servant leadership approach through platforms where the thoughts of the newest team member are also evaluated brings both creativity and increased motivation.

So, aren't there any obstacles to the more horizontal hierarchy being effective?

It is easier and more encouraging at first to ignite enthusiasm for the creative, free power of agile methods and teams. However, the inequality that may be experienced in the gradual ownership of values between teams over time may prevent the same level of communication in teams. Even if the hierarchy is reduced, things can get messy in practice…

Clinging to old habits

Over-assigned roles can affect the ability to assume responsibility. Income models based on seniority, knowledge or goals may conflict with the flexibility of roles. On the other hand, the future career prospects of team leaders may not replace previous privileges.

If we think in terms of leaders at the top, micromanaging over small details, not trusting the team in the decision-making process and not being patient for the teams to make mistakes can empty this structure.

Difficulty in adaptation

While the flexibility of agile organizations allows new generations to adapt quickly as well as showing that more experienced employees are happy, managers may keep thinking in hierarchical terms when they talk about flattening the hierarchy. Employees may also feel this dilemma experienced by their superiors and begin to deprive themselves of effective decision-making methods and experience.

There are also examples of start-ups that at some stage of their growth have returned to classical scaling after starting agile. In short, there is still time today for a well-established experience of how enjoyable it can be to work in high-performing agile teams and how much can be learned about leadership.

Finding the optimal point

So let's ask: What are the factors affecting the optimal point between hierarchy and agility?

  1. Structural factors: The current organization's value creation strategy and the current structure of the market.
  2. Leadership and organizational culture: Management roles in the organization, decision-making style, values, openness to change, taking responsibility and experience of self-organization.
  3. Job descriptions and titles: The company's income, goal and career models, how performance management is done.

Let's leave it here, and the details will be provided in other articles.

In summary, in a world that is advancing to manager-free (holacratic) organizations, the goal is to increase the number of employees by reducing the levels and shifting the decisions to the lower levels. There is no point in changing the number of levels unless you change your thinking and adopt competency-based interaction.

What is clear is that it is impractical and unrealistic to assume that the entire company can be run from a control tower away from the people doing the real work. To achieve the delicate balance between alignment and autonomy, a leadership understanding that will unleash motivation is essential.

The focus of agility should not be bureaucracy and rigid processes, but happy people who know what to do and offer value to the customer.

P.S. You can contact us by clicking here to share your experiences and ask questions about the agile working method.
 

Sources

https://hbrturkiye.com/storage/doc/acm/acm-sayi-1.pdf

https://www.smartsheet.com/content/agile-marketing-guide

https://www.mckinsey.com/tr/our-insights/agile-organizations-agile-transition-and-benefits-for-companies

https://imperiumapps.com/why-all-modern-companies-need-to-adopt-agile/

https://vinod.blog/2013/03/07/agile-adoption-and-roles/

https://breitenstein-consulting.com/en/all-agile-or-what/

The Age of Agile Book, Stephen Denning, February 2018 

Agile People Book, Pia-Maria Thoren, September 2017 

Comments

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.